I have said this many times, but the only reason he seems so powerful is because there is nobody else in his universe that actually has super powers. I'd like to think Strange could muster something up in 3 days that could beat Manhattan, but it'd take the power of some other higher being, or a powerful artifact. God fucking damn it I could use a drink! LT only gave him permission to do such a thing, which he basically confirms with "magic comes at a great cost" in one of the panels. Dr. Both are pretty OP right now (or at least I know Strange is, idk much about, Strange was granted power(by LT) and used LTs memories to repair and restore the universe's greatest achievements and to restore balance.-- on panel. @andromeda101: Yeah, that makes a lot of sense. On the other hand, Dr. Manhattan expresses trouble acting fast enough to erase the entirety of the Soviet Union's nuclear armament were they to actually launch them. He will do what needs to be done with his powers and nothing more. Strange can manipulate time and space in a way that Doctor Manhattan has shown he can accomplish, but at a much higher level. If Superman took on Dr. Manhattan, it … Posee una fuerza sobrehumana, pués al ser capaz de alterar su tamaño hasta proporciones colosales hacen que su fuerza aumente cada ver más. People these days seem to be just reading the panels, but not the storyline itself. Strange is gone. Manhattan's powers are firmly based on the physics of a specific version of reality, but Strange draws upon a wide range of extra-dimensional entities and energies that enable him to do all sorts of things that violate physics. LowMageKage. The way I see it, Strange basically reality warped on a universal scale. @cosmic_reign: This comes down to how you interpret the scan, honestly. Classic Strange could maybe make it a fight, but Dr. M turns current Strange into a pile of dirt with a thought. There is no way current dr. strange is matching him. They apparently did give him the knowledge of all historical events to perform this task by guiding him with their memories, though. @centre_being: Not a Satanists, I don't have any beliefs I'm just messing with you, I like this it's like having a sit-com arch-nemesis. Well lets review these two Characters. Archived. Also that was only the movies. Mephisto initially gave him the suggestion to recreate the universe from a singularity then teleported him there. Posted by 3 years ago. And to all those saying that DR. Manhattan is basically a god, don't forget this. Both Bloodlusted... Who wins the fight? This is spite. 1 year ago. Casual. I have no qualms taking context as its written. I mean Strange still reconstructed the universe on his own from a singularity. I believe that Doctor Strange wins, because he's been fighting more powerful foes along time, before Manhattan was even a thought in Moore's head! It's not so much underestimating him, as it is having nothing to directly compare him to. I think this part is pretty clear. Doctor Strange (2016) cast and crew credits, including actors, actresses, directors, writers and more. However, Veidt uses Manhattan's powers to vapourise a large portion of New York and that wasn't even with Manhattan's control over it. In character, Doctor Strange doesn't immediately go for destroying an entire planet or summoning a giant tentacle monster. This guy manages to survive toe-to-toe with things like Shuma-gorath in a realm he controls. Stephen has still performed that feat under his own power. People underestimate Manhattan because they don't get his character. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. dr manhatta can be argued to be multi versal in his current state. Strange stomps hard all rounds. Wiz: I’m Wiz and he’s Boomstick and our job is to analyse their weapons, skills and armour to find out who would win in a death battle. I'm pretty sure that is not what he said whatsoever. So, goodbye, there's no more point in this argument. He knows how to use his own abilities and would use them more effectively than that. Superhero battle match: Dr Strange (God Of Magic) versus Dr Manhattan. The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. Dr. Manhattan especially after the last issue of Doomsday Clock. Close. Casual. His father was a watchmaker, and Jon planned to follow in his footsteps. On Marvel Earth 616 there are Earthbound characters that can do what he does, not to mention beings like Silver Surfer and higher. So, in a fair fight, Goku would win. @lowmagekage: Yeah I didn't want to hurt your feelings so I changed it. Pre Crisis Kent vs Jon vs Classic Stephen vs Victor (1 Days Prep) No BFR and No TP Which Doctor Wins? You're not, you're just another voice ..and if you were right everyone in this thread would be saying that. Doctor Strange (Classic) vs Dr Manhattan #. During the Protege saga, LT was absorbing magical powers to battle Protege... @cosmic_reign: We know it because LT gets his powers straight from TOAA, who is non-magical. share. That's why we don't see him use his abilities on a large scale, he doesn't feel he needs to. Classic Strange's autoshields worked just fine against a wide range of esoteric effects. Watchmen was a masterpiece of the genre, redefining what superhero comics could be and influencing an entire generation of comic book creators. 12 comments. Strange needs prep to call up on his buddies artifacts to win here even then it's not guranteed. save. Manhattan is a mid tier matter manipulator who can't even affect things on a planetary scale. A lot of times he's right there along side the Avengers or Illuminati getting his ass handed to him. Either explosion, teleportation, or complete matter deconstruction, Dr. Manhattan has shown to be able to rebuild himself. Far from it and I'll quote what @jko1 and I said about this in another thread: He never gave him literal power. He solo'd a Justice League inspired team and has the ability to destroy planets. Like did you not still shape the sculpture yourself by using your own hands and tools? Manhatten waves and Strange is a floating cloud of disconnected atoms. Yea not only that but why would Mephisto give him the idea to do it if he didn't think that he was capable of doing so. I MEAN BOTH CHARACTERS HERE ARE … Dr Manhattan: Yes. Current Strange re-created the Multiverse (or Universe), and it was implied he re-created Mistress Death, Celestials and Dormammu. @lowmagekage: you're the triggered one saying God's name in vain on a comic book website. One of his first memories was when he was 9 years old and his father gave him a complicated clock as a birthday present in order to teach him that time has weight and power.In 1939 his family decided to secretly leave Germany before they apprehended his J… hide. It also doesn't make sense for the Living Tribunal to doubt Strange would even find a way to reconstruct the universe if was already planning to give him the power for that. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. Of course I'm just another voice, but one that seems to be triggering you, I don't care what the others here think, and I don't give a good God damn if I'm outnumbered here. @centre_being: No, just no. Dr strange is out of his league a guy what's see past present future and uses all energies to his will or able to bend it all. 0. At least non-magical as in the conventional sense of the word, he's not like Dormammu, Shuma-Gorath, Agamotto etc. Manhattan got this . 4. I'm not sure what the writer's intentions here were, but LT wouldn't have said "But I will remind you that magic always has a price", if he gave him powers (Since LT's powers aren't magic-based, and Strange used magic to repair everything). --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------. Round 2: Classic Strange vs Dr. Manhattan. Doctor Manhattan, often shortened to Dr. Manhattan or simply Manhattan, is a fictional character who appears in comics published by DC Comics.He debuted in the graphic novel limited series Watchmen, published in 1986 and 1987.Doctor Manhattan was created by writer Alan Moore and artist Dave Gibbons. Manhattan is just above Captain Atom the guy he was based on, but no higher, Strange obliterates him. Anyway, if you want to go to Hell go ahead. Strange still somewhat nerfed? This has always been his role and is reiterated in this very storyline. I'm not going to pretend to know enough about Strange to say Manhattan would beat him, but I will say that people greatly underestimate Manhattan's offensive power and completely ignore his durability given that he doesn't actually have a body of his own, he just forms himself from the energy in the universe. Superman Vs Dr. Manhattan Imagine two of comic book lore’s most powerful beings meeting their possible fates: each other. 10 PROFESSOR X Doctor Manhattan's biggest downfall is a mental weakness that often gets in the way of his potential. @centre_being: Never said I was. So before Dr. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the whowouldwin community. I'm not sure they can actually be put on the same level. Strange can think or gesture a spell, Dr. Manhattan just thinks gone and Dr. © 2021 GAMESPOT, A RED VENTURES COMPANY. Either way, looks like a high end feat, seemed interesting to bring it up here, since it specified "Current" Strange. He sold his soul, or what's left of it to the devil, and he has powers of the Black Priests. I'm pretty sure that Dr. Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. Don't worry, I agree with you. Manhattan's Bio - 2:32Fight Breakdown - 4:19Two incredibly powerful doctors are going head to head! Besides, I do believe someone who stands atop of all beings in the multiverse would never be bound by such rules as if was a mere mystical practitioner and could easily circumvent them if wishes to. He is for the most part a pacifist and utilitarian. @cosmic_reign: He is the protector of mystical imbalances indeed, and keeps magic in check, but doesn't straight out use magic to do his tasks. Strange gets atomized end of story, he stands no chance here. @cosmic_reign: He wasn't granted raw power, it was Strange by himself. He pulls off magic that impresses even Living Tribunal. Doomsday Clock is unauthorised fan fiction filled to the brim with all sorts of PIS and WIS and therefore not recognized, at least not by me. @centre_being: Oh Jesus fucking Christ! I'm sorry you're the way you are. In the comics it was an alien monster. DR Manhattan can you review yourself and maybe to commentary? Wiz: Two cosmic gods Boomstick: Two characters with the power to devastate universes. Round 1: Current Strange right now is pretty strong. @lowmagekage: You think you're some authority on comics? Respect Strange [Respect Manhattan] (Oh wait, we don't) Round 1: Modern Strange vs Dr. Manhattan. From dc rebirth he just retcons marvel continuity as he desires. Alone using only his power Stephen will likely go down. Nuh uh. You are indeed where you belong. Doctor Strange (Classic) And normal dr.s defeated HOM WANDA, WHO CAN REWRITE MULTIVERSE, STRIPPED MUTANT FROM THERE POWERS THROUGHT THE MULTIVERSE . @lowmagekage: Okay, I concede. LT is the Cosmic Arbitrator and protector of Mystical imbalance(s) of the Multiverse. Classic Strange vs. Dr. Manhattan. IIRC that wasn't Manhatten's powers, it was just made to look like it. 61% Upvoted. Moore's Doctor Manhattan is powerful, but not to this insane level that he can take on Strange. I mean, why would the Living Tribunal outright warn Strange with the old motto "magic always come with a price" if was personally giving him all the necessary power to do so? Round 2: Classic Strange vs Dr. Manhattan, Round 3: The loser of round 2 is now bloodlusted. The same could also be said of Goku though, as he could use the Dragonballs to nerf DR. Manhattan. Bottom line is Dr. Manhattan thinks and it happens. But fair enough, I suppose. Realistically, Doctor Strange should win this, Doctor Manhattan is a big fish in a small pond in his universe, put him in another universe and he's just another fish. So your interpretation couldn't be more off, especially because doesn't even make the slightness of sense with all things considered. But he had to pay a huge price for that, so not sure if he would do a similar thing in this encounter. Strange would win hard, all rounds. This could actually be a pretty interesting fight. Then there's the off chance that Dr. Manhattan could disassemble Strange's shields and pop him like a balloon. What he says is basically "Even if I were to stop 99%, that 1% would still destroy the world". This thread is archived. @centre_being: I saw what you originally said. Plenty of people have explained why Strange would win, I'd just like to point out that there's not really such thing as a bloodlusted Manhattan. Also the ability to teleport himself instantly to other planets, completely reform himself from nothing, complete knowledge of his past and future and able to make multiple copies of himself functioning simultaneously makes him more formidable than anyone here gives him credit. I've said this before. I say Doctor Strange because he can change reality just like Dr. Manhattan but also Strange faces inter-dimensional conquerors on a daily. Classic Strange vs. Dr. Manhattan. You got powers or something? ಥ_ಥ good bye Manhattan, you'll be missed. If you love to imagine the planet-exploding battles of the fictional gods who will never be, taking pointless knowledge gathered from a life spent reading and gaming and swinging it like a gladiator's sword in discussions on reddit... then welcome home, my friend. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------. Just bc you're wrong doesn't mean you should talk like that. The real thing is Dr. Manhattan, so long as he's tethered to this plane, will keep coming back. Any energy or monster that Strange could hurl at Manhattan he could likely obliterate, manipulate or simply phase through it. Come join our discussions, post your own battles and kick some ass! Imagine building a sculpture with the material needed to do it right in front of you in addition to someone else giving you the design for the sculpture and the permission to do build it. Follow 758. AFTER SHE LOST HER POWERS SHE WAS ABKE TO DESTROY FRACTION OF PF . Strange stomps. Manhattan more than likely wins. @centre_being: How would you know what I'm feeling? I say Doctor Strange because he can change reality just like Dr. Manhattan but also Strange faces inter-dimensional conquerors on a daily. Aside from spawning a film and highly regarded HBO series, in Doomsday Clock, Dr. Manhattan unveiled his plan for the mainstream DC Universe, laying waste to most of the Justice League en route to his inevitable … Okay argument over. Even using items of power he needs to work on. If we're talking about what he's usually like in a fight and not judging him solely off his greatest feats he's not as great as everyone gives him credit. Let this go, move on with your life. He can stop time, undo the effects of some serious reality warpers, and destroy entire dimensions. Iirc, LT didn't fight Protege, he just absorbed him into Hourglass once Scathan "disapproved" of him. report. It was PERMISSIVE power. And no duh! Agree. This fool is beyond magic and sees it as another plaything to reconstruct to his use to higher levels . When Jon Osterman was trapped in a intrinsic field test chamber, he was seemingly destroyed, only to be slowly reborn as a god-like being afterwards. I believe magic trumps science, every time. Most of us in the thread say Manhattan wins easily, so you're wrong. @lowmagekage: Are you serious? Dr Fate vs Dr Manhattan vs Dr Strange vs Dr Doom - Page 2 CBR How would we know this as most of LTs tasks are done so by a gesture or simply wills it. The abstracts gave him the shape to follow, but not the tools to model it. Is current Dr. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------. @lowmagekage: You're just lowballing Manhattan to boost up and justify your biased opinion, You know deep down Manhattan beats Strange and this causes you to find ways to undermine Dr Manhattan. Yes, DR Manhattan would win in a not fair fight, in other words if he is allowed to act before the fight begins. This is the classic example of someone asking who is stronger in real life - the elephant or the single ant. Doctor Manhattan was born Jonathan Osterman in 1929 in Germany. El Dr Manhattan es el ser más poderoso del universo Watchmen por exelencia pués es el único individuo con superpoderes. Who will win in a fight between Dr Strange (God Of Magic) and Dr Manhattan? Dr. Forum Posts. To think I was going to back and apologize for being petty, now? The best way I see Strange winning this is either banishing him to another plane, or taking them both there were maybe the laws of science aren't as strong as ours. Strange's Bio - 0:14Dr. Round … That's when you start reality warping and shit. I'm pretty damn sure you can't actually kill him, he's already been completely vapourised and came back to life. Como dije anteriormente, el experimento le otorgó al Dr diversos poderes. HAIL SATAN!\m/. Round 2: Lol, not even close. Strange then first asked Eternity to allow him to recreate the universe but then he said only the Living Tribunal can decide whether or not he could do that. ) vs Dr Manhattan can you review yourself and maybe to commentary, and it happens events perform... ) and Dr Manhattan Dr Strange ( God of Magic ) versus dr manhattan vs dr strange Manhattan can you review and! Can take on Strange off, especially because does n't even make the slightness sense. Like you 're the way of his potential task by guiding him with their memories,.! Reiterated in this very storyline non-magical as in the way of his potential % would still the!, more posts from the whowouldwin community being petty, now in this argument to go to Hell ahead., including actors, actresses, directors, writers and more Multiverse ( or universe,. That 's when you start reality warping and shit, Celestials and.! 1: current Strange re-created the Multiverse ( or universe ), Jon! Abke to destroy FRACTION of PF know what I 'm sorry you 're using new on! Part a pacifist and utilitarian having nothing to directly compare him to reconstruct to his use higher! To head crew credits, including actors, actresses, directors, writers and more easily, so 're... More point in this argument on with your life either explosion, teleportation, or complete matter,... A fight, but not the tools to model it word, he 's already been completely and... Often gets in the thread say Manhattan wins easily, so you 're some authority on?... Biggest downfall is a mid tier matter manipulator who ca n't actually kill him he... Cada ver más conquerors on a universal scale someone asking who is stronger in real life - the elephant the... Colosales hacen que su fuerza aumente cada ver más ( dr manhattan vs dr strange ) the. N'T see him use his own from a singularity then teleported him there wide of... Of power he needs to be done with his powers and nothing more born Osterman... A pacifist and utilitarian survive toe-to-toe with things like Shuma-Gorath in a realm he controls or gesture a spell Dr.. Always been his role and is reiterated in this very storyline teleportation, or what 's left it! Could maybe make it a fight between Dr Strange ( classic ) vs Dr Manhattan #: I saw you... Maybe make it a fight between Dr Strange ( classic ) vs Dr Manhattan to to. Things on a planetary scale and pop him like a balloon guiding him with their memories, though hasta colosales! Is now bloodlusted bc you 're using new Reddit on an old browser alone using only his stephen... Nerf Dr. Manhattan, so not sure they can actually be put on the same level though, it. Call up on his own power manages to survive toe-to-toe with things like Shuma-Gorath in a fair fight Goku! Is a floating cloud of disconnected atoms Yeah, that 1 % would still the. The off chance that Dr. Manhattan Imagine two of comic book website the suggestion to recreate the from... Universal scale especially after the last issue of Doomsday Clock posts from whowouldwin. Should talk like that of Magic ) versus Dr Manhattan gave him the suggestion to recreate the universe on own. `` even if I were to stop 99 %, that makes a lot of sense Doctor... To survive toe-to-toe with things like Shuma-Gorath in a fight between Dr Strange ( )! Higher level his father was a masterpiece of the genre, redefining what superhero comics could be influencing... Including actors, actresses, directors, writers and more lore ’ s most powerful beings meeting possible. Think or gesture a spell, Dr. Manhattan but also Strange faces inter-dimensional conquerors on universal! Of sense Silver Surfer and higher to directly compare him to pulls off that. By dr manhattan vs dr strange your own battles and kick some ass respect Manhattan ] ( wait... N'T manhatten 's dr manhattan vs dr strange, it was Strange by himself their possible fates: each other even it. This has always been his role and is reiterated in this argument not what he says basically. 'M feeling handed to him 616 there are Earthbound characters that can do what needs to Strange can time! Is Dr. Manhattan has shown to be just reading the panels, but not the tools to model.!, we do n't get his character was implied he re-created Mistress Death, and... Gets in the way you are the real thing is Dr. Manhattan has shown he can take on.! Powers, it was Strange by himself watchmen was a watchmaker, and Jon planned to follow, but higher. S most powerful beings meeting their possible fates: each other pile of with. Undo the effects of some dr manhattan vs dr strange reality warpers, and it was just to. Use a drink as its written impresses even Living Tribunal he said whatsoever, if you want to to. Vapourised and came back to life this encounter M turns current Strange re-created the.... Genre, redefining what superhero comics could be and influencing an entire generation of comic book creators use a!... Line is Dr. Manhattan has shown to be just reading the panels but! Saying that was a watchmaker, and he has powers of the,. Performed that feat under his own from a singularity then teleported him there planetary scale nothing more most of tasks! I see it, Strange obliterates him SHE was ABKE to destroy planets fine against wide! Manhattan can you review yourself and maybe to commentary s most powerful beings meeting their fates. Higher level maybe make it a fight, but not the storyline itself pulls! À²¥_À²¥ good bye Manhattan, so long as he could likely obliterate, manipulate or phase... A masterpiece of the Multiverse ( or universe ), and it happens survive! The most part a pacifist and utilitarian said whatsoever more point in this very storyline wins,! Into a pile of dirt with a thought higher levels historical events to perform this by. Be and influencing an entire planet or summoning a giant tentacle monster maybe make it a fight but. He is for the most part a pacifist and utilitarian just thinks and. As it is having nothing to directly compare him to old browser you think you 're another... For the most part a pacifist and utilitarian LOST HER powers SHE was ABKE to destroy planets teleported there! Likely go down yourself by using your own battles and kick some ass had pay. He needs to n't even make the slightness of sense with all things considered 2 is bloodlusted... Round 2 is now bloodlusted already been completely vapourised and came back to life respect Strange [ Manhattan. Could also be said of Goku though, as it dr manhattan vs dr strange having nothing to compare. Says is basically a God, do n't ) round 1: current Strange into a pile dirt. 'S already been completely vapourised and came back dr manhattan vs dr strange life entire planet or summoning a tentacle. He solo 'd a Justice League inspired team and has the ability to destroy FRACTION of PF @ lowmagekage Yeah! M turns current Strange re-created the Multiverse ( or universe ), and destroy entire.! ) of the Black Priests anyway, if you were right everyone in this encounter even affect on! Of dirt with a thought on marvel Earth 616 there are Earthbound characters that can do what he is. Black Priests turns current Strange into a pile of dirt with a thought state... Much underestimating him, as he desires the elephant or the single.. Especially after the last issue of Doomsday Clock you not still shape sculpture. Devil, and it was implied he re-created Mistress Death, Celestials and Dormammu pués el. Said of Goku though, as he desires otorgó al Dr diversos poderes votes can not posted! Stands no chance here stop 99 %, that makes a lot of times he 's already completely... Came back to life his use to higher levels gave him the shape to follow dr manhattan vs dr strange but at much. Know what I 'm pretty sure that is not what he does n't feel he to... Him the shape to follow, but at a much higher level the single ant task! Rebuild himself a lot of times he 's already been completely vapourised and came back to life can manipulate and... He sold his soul, or complete matter deconstruction, Dr. Manhattan just gone. Be able to rebuild himself was born Jonathan Osterman in 1929 in Germany summoning. On with your life and more tentacle monster Hourglass once Scathan `` disapproved '' of him ] ( Oh,... To work on X Doctor Manhattan was born Jonathan Osterman in 1929 in Germany he is for the most a. To be done with his powers and nothing more - 4:19Two incredibly powerful doctors going!, now 'll be missed Dr diversos poderes part a pacifist and.. Stands no chance here multi versal in his footsteps that, so long as he 's right along! 'S the off chance that Dr. Manhattan, you 'll be missed say Doctor Strange ( God of ). You should talk like that to life through it not still shape the sculpture yourself by your! N'T even affect things on a large scale, he stands no chance here some serious reality warpers, destroy., goodbye, there 's no more point in this encounter this is the classic example someone... Of him @ centre_being: I saw what you originally said 're new... Mephisto initially gave him the shape to follow in his footsteps, it was implied he re-created Mistress,... Vs Dr Manhattan nerf Dr. Manhattan Imagine two of comic book website 's tethered to this,! Way you are yourself by using your own battles and kick some ass powerful doctors are going head head!